3PL Vs 4PL: How to Choose for Your Business?

Two people working at a table on Microsoft Surface tablets with blue keyboards.

Key Takeaways

3PL providers focus on specific logistics tasks like shipping and warehousing. 4PL providers manage the whole supply chain, including 3PL services.

3PL:

Handles specific tasks
Focuses on day-to-day operations
Works directly with your company

4PL:

Manages the whole supply chain
Develops long-term strategies
Coordinates multiple partners

Different Logistic Level

A logistic level refers to the degree of outsourcing in a company’s supply chain management. It indicates the number of parties involved and the scope of services provided by external partners. Except the 3PL and 4PL mentioned before, it also has 1PL, 2PL, 5PL and ect.

1PL (First-Party Logistics): Companies handle their own logistics internally, managing transportation, warehousing, and inventory themselves.
2PL (Second-Party Logistics): Companies outsource transportation services to a carrier or freight forwarder, but still manage warehousing and inventory themselves.

What is 3PL and 4PL?

3PL stands for third-party logistics. These companies handle specific parts of your supply chain. They might take care of warehousing, shipping, or inventory management for you.

4PL means fourth-party logistics. These providers go a step further. They manage your entire supply chain from start to finish. This includes overseeing 3PLs and other partners.

Choosing between 3PL and 4PL depends on your needs. If you need someone to manage everything, a 4PL could be the way to go.

Core Services and Capabilities

A worker in a hard hat and safety vest moves boxes on a hand truck in a warehouse.

Transportation and Warehousing

3PLs shine in moving and storing your goods. They have trucks, warehouses, and shipping know-how. You can pick which services you need.

These providers offer flexible storage options. You might use their warehouse space during busy seasons. They can also handle your shipping needs. This includes local deliveries or international freight.

4PLs take a wider approach. They don’t just provide transport and storage. Instead, they find the best mix of services for you. They might use different 3PLs for various tasks. Their goal is to create the most efficient system for your business.

Customer Service and Fulfillment

3PLs is a order fulfillment service provider. They pick, pack, and ship products to your customers. Some offer return processing too. This can save you time and space in your own facilities.

Many 3PLs provide tracking info for shipments. This helps keep your customers in the loop. Some even offer call center services to handle customer questions.

4PLs take the logistics service to the next level. They look at the whole customer experience.

With a 4PL, you will have a single point of contact to manage all your transportation and operational requirements. This includes how orders are placed, fulfilled, and delivered. They aim to make the entire process smooth for you and your customers.

4PLs use data to improve service. They track trends and suggest ways to serve customers better. This might mean changing shipping methods or inventory locations.

Strategic Management and Supply Chain Optimization

A transportation collage features an airplane, cargo ship, train, and truck with a globe and city skyline in the background for global logistics.

4PL providers offer big-picture management of your entire supply chain. They focus on strategy and long-term improvements. This helps make your operations smoother and more efficient.

Supply Chain Management and Strategy

4PL partners take charge of your whole supply chain. They look at the big picture and make plans to help your business grow. These experts can:

Set up smart shipping routes
Find ways to save money
Pick the best suppliers for you

How to Choose Between 3PL and 4PL?

Deciding between a 3PL and a 4PL for your logistics operations and supply chain requires careful consideration of several factors. Here’s a breakdown to help you make the best choice:

Difference between 3pl and 4pl

Feature	3PL	4PL
Services	Transportation, warehousing, inventory management, value-added services	Comprehensive supply chain management, strategic planning, optimization, technology integration
Focus	Operational efficiency, cost reduction	Strategic planning, process improvement, innovation
Expertise	Specific industry or logistics function	Cross-functional expertise, industry knowledge
Control	Client retains control over most decisions	4PL manages the supply chain with client input
Cost	Typically lower than 4PL	Higher than 3PL
Relationship	Transactional	Collaborative partnership

When to Choose a Third-party logistics:

Simple supply chain: If your supply chain is straightforward and you have the resources to manage some aspects internally, a 3PL can handle core logistics tasks efficiently.
Cost-focused: 3PLs often offer competitive rates, making them ideal for cost-conscious companies.
Limited expertise: If you lack in-house logistics expertise, a 3PL can provide the necessary knowledge and resources.

When to Choose a 4PL:

Complex supply chain: A 4PL can handle intricate supply chains with multiple stakeholders and diverse requirements.
Strategic focus: If you want to optimize your entire supply chain and gain a competitive advantage, a 4PL can provide strategic insights and guidance.
Limited resources: 4PLs can free up your internal resources to focus on core business activities.
Desire for collaboration: A 4PL acts as an extension of your team, collaborating closely to achieve your goals.

Why Choose Luckystar?

Established in 2022, Luckystar is a Non-Vessel Operating Common Carrier (NVOCC) dedicated to providing top-notch shipping services. With over 20 years of industry experience, our team excels in delivering superior international freight solutions from China to the US and Canada.

Luckystar: Lead of Logistics Provider

Timeliness: We prioritize accurate and timely deliveries, which are essential for businesses that require prompt customer service.
Global Network: Our extensive reach spans the globe, helping to expand your business opportunities.
Real-Time Tracking: Monitor your shipment’s progress at every stage for complete peace of mind.
Tailored Support: Our dedicated team members manage your shipment from beginning to end, keeping you informed throughout the entire process.
Expertise in Hazardous Materials: We specialize in the safe and efficient handling of hazardous materials.

Frequently Asked Questions

In what ways does 5PL logistics differ from 3PL and 4PL?

5PL providers focus on network optimization. They use technology to manage multiple supply chains.

3PLs and 4PLs typically work with one company’s supply chain. 5PLs often manage logistics across several companies.

5PLs aim to create the most efficient supply chain network possible. They rely heavily on data and advanced tech.

Does Amazon function as a 3PL or 4PL, and why?

Amazon acts more like a 3PL for most sellers. They offer warehousing and shipping through Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA).

For some larger partners, Amazon’s services might resemble 4PL. They can provide more comprehensive supply chain solutions.

Amazon’s main focus is on specific logistics tasks, not full supply chain management for most users.